I think jmpancoast said it all. I have the HD Compact Quick Release on my Street Bob. Is there Buffeting...yes at times, depends on how the wind is blowing and how I have my legs positioned. So size, type of controls, mid v. forward, size of the rider etc. all effect whether or not you get the buffetting. Overall, I would say I am very happy with the shield. I am 6' and have mid-controls with highway pegs (little to no buffetting with my feet on either). As was said if you want one, go for it, and I recommend the HD one, it is a quality product.