Like Sc Says, plus I think baggers look better with a pipe on both sides, kinds of balances things out. The 09 also comes from the factory with cruise control, which I really like. ( 300.00 option on 10 ). There is something to be said about resale, but that can also be used for a barganing tool. I would say if you could beat him down in price, say 700.00 or more for the 09, plus the cruise. I would say the 09 would be a good buy. Kind of depends on the person, Like some else said : Walk around them, look them over. Either way I don't think you can go wrong.