I was in the same boat as you a few months ago...only I don't have two Softails (you so Lucky!!) I am also the kind of guy that will research an item to death before I make a decision. I looked up the Scientific data on the major synthetics after determining that syn was the way to go. Mobil1 has a very good rating if you compare the data, I am not oil techie but Mobil1 had the higher numbers in the areas that count...sulfur and ash, burn and pour rates and breakdown...I don't understand it but my buddy is a bulk plant manager (not a mobile1 carrier) and even he told me that Mobil1 was better than thier best comparable brand and a few dollars cheaper by the quart. I used Spectro for primary and as soon as I modify a 3/8" allen to fit and clear the exhaust I will use Spectro for my tranny. again, this is after hours of reading these posts and using google and other resources to decide. Right now I am trying to decide which home theater system to get for our new led tv...so far Onkyo is leading, but need to look up Bose just to see if they are worth the big $$ difference. Never send me to the store to buy breakfast cereal, it is a long process for me...lol:shock