Did your warranty cover the replacement? The service manager at my dealer told me I could pay to have them checked and if they needed to be replaced the extended service plan would pay to replace them. This not true?
They are probably only going to replace like-for-like. That then just gives you new spring loaded tensioners rather then one of the up-grade options. Most of us would recommend the roller chain conversion or even the gear drive as an alternative to the spring-loaded tensioners.
Check this:
Roller Chain Conversion white paper
Roller-chain Conversion - Harley Davidson Community
TQ