Just installed the Black LED in my 09 FXDL! Parts guy at HD said it was NOT cataloged for mine but he had installed the chrome one on 05+ Dynas without any problems.
Fit with no problems, was careful with the wires. The connecter is not solidly connected to the light, it is on wires coming from the light, made sure they were not directly behind light in case depth was an issue. Did use with visor style trim ring #69735-05 which is cataloged for Dyna 94+ Looks and works GREAT! Now have ALL LEDs on Lowrider!