Whatever boot you decide...my preference 1) Fit is #1, 2) Construction is #2, the sole pattern should be fairly aggressive, oil resistant neoprene, double sewn welt, uppers leather (personal preference) 3) Wellington slip-on (fitted to be rather snug yet not too loose around the thighs. 4) Sale/discounted price...made in USA preferred, but I have found Chippawa, Red Wing, Wolverines and other off the shelf brands (yes even some H-D ones are fine), only IF you find the points mentioned hit the most criteria you choose. Funny, I ended up with a very nice pair of H-D boots and for less than $100, which fit me...lettomg opportunity and emotions close the deal (as is usually the case) when dealing with our sport. :s