I know this was not one of the choices, but, if you can get your butt in a Corbin try that on out for a long ride. I have a gunfighter and lady on my softail that i really, really like. The wife really likes the Corbin as well. My FX came with a Badlander, and ocassionally put it on because I like the way it looks, but, I really can't wait to get the Corbin back on. I am considering putting the Badlander on Craigslist.