Whenever I read posts about HD and pricing and attitude of dealers, I'm amazed.
1. My dealer in Central Indiana has been absolutely superb! Service has been excellent, and they really treat me like a family
2. I priced a Gold Wing last year at $24,000 and bought my 105th Anniversary Ultra Glide for $24,000. Gold Wing had built in Navigation and reverse gear, my Harley has a Garmin Zumo 550 wired to bike, and no reverse.
3. We priced Sportsters for my wife at $8,000 against Honda Shadow 1200 at $8,000. She ultimately bought a Kawasaki Vulcan 900 touring bike for $8,500 because she didn't want the larger, heavier Dyna or Low boy.
I think the issue is that HD doesn't make a bike that fits in the crotch rocket lighter weight fiberglass futuristic look. Buell is trying, but its tough. Once you go away from the big bikes, or for that matter BMW and Mercedes cars that sell a life style you get into Toyota, Honda, Nissan, and like bike makers selling vanilla, high quality machines.
BTW, The MOCO is not making a lot of money. Buying American and leaving room for almost unlimited customization ADDS COST compared to rather generic bikes made in Japan where the yen to dollar conversion ratio has been very favorable.
The long term prospects for HD are questionable because of a lifestyle change. Young people want to be different than their parents and grandparents. They are very self centered as well and don't see the charity rides and support of others as part of their weekend life style. One exception might be the military men and women returning from the Mideast, but even there they have a special camaraderie built around their personal peer group. There may never again be the kind of demographics that allowed HD to become larger and better as a company again.
Hopefully, they will continue to fill a niche that enough folks will follow to keep the company active...but just like other parts of the baby boomer mystic, it may be coming to an end.