Agree that you need to check all cable connections, make sure the cables are clean... and tight.
My guess would be that the battery is too old, and it is past it's "Due Date".
Battery's only last about 3-5 years anymore, less in the colder states. less with a bike with mucho electrical accessories. I figure it's cheap insurance to just go ahead and buy a new one at least every 4 years, and use a Battery Tender if she sits more than a week, or it's colder (<35 F) outside.
It's extremely hard to diagnose stuff without seeing it, but hope this maybe helps.:eam
Bob
I don't think lower octane gas would be the culprit. Lower octance gas is actually easier to ignite and in cold weather it might actually aid in starting.
gotta agree with Prophet and Tank here. Cold weather is harder on a battery than heat due to trying to "heat up" the plates / acid inside and if your battery is the same age as the 05 your riding , I would - JMO - look at getting a replacement. The battery has alot more jobs to do other than just firing up the bike. This is twice as you stated youve had trouble starting it when the temps drop. Now if you have a fairly new battery installed , I would check ALL of my connections , etc.
Agree with Tank with the "lower" octane fuel being the cause of the trouble. might cause some spitting & sputtering but dont believe it would cause this. Either put some fuel cleaner of your choice in it or run it down to about a 3/4 to 1/2 a tank then go back with some mid or high octane. Another - JMO - thing to keep in mind not everyone buys high octane for their cars/trucks/bikes so you run the risk of getting some stale fuel.